Firewood and the forests

The recent RSPB scare report that the expansion of wood-based energy in the UK will result in “swathes of forests overseas being logged” reminds me of the parallel debate in tropical forest countries.

The equivalent of a biomass power station in rural Africa and Asia is the household wood-burning cookstove, also widely condemned for its damaging wood consumption.

However, a major forest report published in June by the US-based Union of Concerned Scientists was scathing that “NGOs still claim that firewood is a major driver of deforestation.” Asserting that most firewood is dead material, UCS insists that “in most parts of Sub-Saharan Africa, firewood collection and trade is considered sustainable.”

This brought a swift blog response from The Center for People and Forests, a leading forest group working in the Asia-Pacific region: “it is a mistaken assumption that fuel wood collection activities are too small in scale to have significant impacts.”

This debate must be resolved because fuel-efficient stoves are the rage in development circles, many projects trying to hook themselves to a business model involving REDD-based carbon credits, for which reduced deforestation must be proven. Of course, forest carbon trading is another topic desperately seeking consensus…


this post was first published by OneWorld UK

Comments are closed.

Switch to our mobile site